Posts Tagged 'bin 389'

Penfolds – Nice wine, pity about the price, and then…..Nice wine, good price

I rarely wander into a wine shop and buy off the shelf. I usually know what I’m looking for and I’ve got a fair idea of the price. There are exceptions – I will take advice from people I trust and they know who they are because I buy from them.

But, to be fair, I thought I’d throw my prejudices to the wind and start having a look around at wine shopping in Singapore in general. What better place to start than Cold Storage. Now I’m not a regular shopper for wine at Cold Storage, but from time to time, something pops up that shouts “buy me”. So, to the test…

I picked the first two wines on the shelf, and the brand is Penfolds.

Now Penfolds produce some outstanding wines (Grange for example) but there’s a lot of, how should we say it, bbq wine at the other end (but not at my bbq). The two wines I’m looking at here are Bin 389, often called the poor man’s Grange, and Bin 128, certainly in the mid to upper range of Penfolds line up.

Here’s the data:

2006 / Penfolds / Bin 389 / South Australia / Cabernet Shiraz / S$102 – The Australian raters love this wine, with Halliday giving it 96 points (5 star), and Epicure giving it 5 stars too. It’s one for the cellar though as Halliday suggests it’ll last until 2036 and Epicure to at least 2024. No good for my cellar then! Wine Spectator is less keen only giving it 4 stars, with a price of US$36. The retail price in Australia is A$55. Sorry, run that past me again. That’s right, A$55. Now, I can tweak A$55 every which way, add GST, add freight, add the duty, and no matter how much I tweak it, I can’t make it come anywhere near S$102.

2006 / Penfolds / Bin 128 / Coonawarra / Shiraz / S$70.05 – Halliday gives it 93 points (4.5 stars) and suggests drinking 2017-2027, so another keeper. Same old story on the price though. Retail price downunder is A$30, so who knows what’s going into the price to get it to S$70.

I haven’t given up on Cold Storage, but with these two in particular, I’ll leave you to be the judge.

BUT you can buy Penfolds at a decent price, a very decent price. Wine Exchange Asia has the following on offer, and if past experience is anything to go by, you’ll have to be quick. I’ve bought mine.

2007 / Penfolds / Koonunga Hill Seventy Six / Shiraz-Cabernet / S$35, S$32 by the case – Halliday rates this 94 (4.5 stars) drinking 2010-2020, and Oliver rates it 93 (still 4.5 stars) with drinking 2015 – 2019. On offer in Australia at A$20 so at S$35/S$32 it definitely falls acceptably inside my PPB (price pain barrier). Over to you.

Advertisements

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 74 other followers

Wine quotations

"A good bottle of wine contains more philosophy than all the books in the world" - Louis Pasteur

“The unexacting palates of the masses…are content to ask no question [on origin] so long as a florin or half-a-crown will purchase a roomy flagon of strong , full-bodied, fruity wine” – CE Hawker writing in 1907

Advertisements